Show filters
Sort by
  1. Find companies
  2. Restaurants
  3. Shelter Island
Hold On!

Don’t leave so soon. You can test our service for

30 days for free!
Start now

The best Restaurants in Shelter Island

7 results with 3801 reviews from multiple sources

Slice pizza

4.85/5
199 reviews from 4 sources
3 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

Vine Street Cafe

4.67/5
1812 reviews from 4 sources
41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

Maria's Kitchen

4.66/5
474 reviews from 4 sources
55 Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

Kyle's Restaurant - bakery, breakfast, lunch, brunch

4.59/5
179 reviews from 4 sources
27 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

18 Bay

4.50/5
500 reviews from 4 sources
23 N. Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

Tuck Shop

4.37/5
49 reviews from 4 sources
75 MENANTIC ROAD, Shelter Island
Details Write a review

The Islander

4.18/5
588 reviews from 4 sources
63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
Details Write a review
MAP LIST