Show filters
Sort by
  1. Find companies
  2. Pizza Restaurants
  3. New Glarus
Hold On!

Don’t leave so soon. You can test our service for

30 days for free!
Start now

The best Pizza Restaurants in New Glarus

4 results with 2026 reviews from multiple sources

Sugar River Pizza Company

4.49/5
1561 reviews from 4 sources
700 Railroad St, New Glarus
Details Write a review

Ticino Pizzeria

4.07/5
136 reviews from 4 sources
100 6th Ave, New Glarus
Details Write a review

Sportsmans Bar & Grill

3.94/5
209 reviews from 4 sources
506 1St St, New Glarus
Details Write a review

Casey's

3.87/5
120 reviews from 4 sources
1019 State Hwy 69, New Glarus
Details Write a review
MAP LIST