Show filters
Sort by
  1. Find companies
  2. Italian Restaurants
  3. Staten Island
Hold On!

Don’t leave so soon. You can test our service for

30 days for free!
Start now

The best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island

101 results with 151042 reviews from multiple sources

Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria

4.92/5
3024 reviews from 3 sources
15 Giffords Lane, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Pizza Mia

4.87/5
7548 reviews from 4 sources
529 Tompkins Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

4.88/5
1578 reviews from 4 sources
97 Lincoln Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Casa Verde Restaurant

4.87/5
1585 reviews from 3 sources
3471 Richmond Road, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Paesano's Pizzeria

4.86/5
1256 reviews from 3 sources
12 Bradley Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Prime Pizza Kitchen

4.84/5
7130 reviews from 4 sources
1778 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Town Deli & Pizzeria

4.84/5
8621 reviews from 3 sources
5373 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Classic Pizza

4.85/5
1165 reviews from 4 sources
3201 Richmond Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Amici Brick Oven Pizza - Staten Island, NY

4.82/5
4992 reviews from 4 sources
6309 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

DiLeo's Pizzeria

4.81/5
2094 reviews from 2 sources
2491 Victory Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Joe & Pat Pizzeria

4.79/5
6269 reviews from 3 sources
1758 VICTORY BLVD, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Il Forno

4.79/5
1717 reviews from 4 sources
6382 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

North Shore Pizza

4.79/5
600 reviews from 4 sources
1376 Forest Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Ciros Pizza Cafe

4.77/5
3984 reviews from 4 sources
862 HUGUENOT AVENUE, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Ariemmas Italian Deli

4.76/5
897 reviews from 4 sources
1791 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Restaurant On The Plaza Pizzeria

4.75/5
592 reviews from 4 sources
50 NEW DORP PLAZA, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe

4.76/5
600 reviews from 3 sources
1298 Forest Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Michelangelo's

4.72/5
1111 reviews from 3 sources
860 Post Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Village Maria Pizzeria II

4.72/5
1598 reviews from 2 sources
768 MANOR RD, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Jimmy Max

4.71/5
2754 reviews from 3 sources
280 Watchogue Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Metro Pizza and Restaurant

4.71/5
920 reviews from 4 sources
1218 Forest Ave., Staten Island
Details Write a review

DOUGH by Licastri

4.70/5
3003 reviews from 4 sources
1456 Richmond Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Nini's Cafe & P K's Lounge

4.79/5
24 reviews from 2 sources
710 NEW DORP LN, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Giuliana's

4.68/5
715 reviews from 3 sources
4105 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Villa Paradiso

4.67/5
774 reviews from 4 sources
145 Greaves Ln, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Michael Anthony

4.71/5
78 reviews from 2 sources
307 Nelson Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

PastaVino

4.64/5
1227 reviews from 4 sources
44 Navy Pier Ct, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Frank And Danny's

4.63/5
2805 reviews from 4 sources
4369 Amboy Road, Staten Island
Details Write a review

The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

4.62/5
2002 reviews from 4 sources
1718 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Trattoria Toscana

4.63/5
392 reviews from 2 sources
4200 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Basil Cucina & Catering

4.59/5
5056 reviews from 3 sources
1686 Forest Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Deninos Pizzeria Tavern

4.60/5
2902 reviews from 3 sources
524 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island
If I could rank their pizza from 1 to 10, their pizza would get 11! It just has this amazing taste! ...
by Gloria B. Smith on 06/10/2010
Details Write a review

Basilio Inn Restaurant

4.59/5
1253 reviews from 4 sources
6 Galesville Court, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Dani's Italian Bistro

4.62/5
171 reviews from 2 sources
7331 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Italianissimo Restaurant

4.57/5
1339 reviews from 4 sources
107 MCCLEAN AVE, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Portofino Pizza

4.58/5
310 reviews from 4 sources
55 Gunton Pl, suite 1, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Ninos Restaurant

4.56/5
2285 reviews from 4 sources
1110 HYLAN BOULEVARD, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Enoteca Maria

4.57/5
1145 reviews from 3 sources
27 Hyatt St, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Reggiano's

4.55/5
2100 reviews from 3 sources
7339 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

LA Strada Restaurant

4.56/5
668 reviews from 2 sources
139 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Gino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.54/5
946 reviews from 4 sources
1351 FOREST AVE, Staten Island
Details Write a review

The Manor Restaurant

4.55/5
756 reviews from 3 sources
917 Manor Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Bocelli

4.53/5
2236 reviews from 4 sources
1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Bari's Pizza

4.52/5
5930 reviews from 4 sources
596 Bay St, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Piccolino

4.53/5
1208 reviews from 4 sources
3935 Amboy Road, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Cucina Fresca

4.53/5
433 reviews from 4 sources
2110 Richmond Rd Ste 5, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Domenico's Pizzeria

4.54/5
164 reviews from 2 sources
3295 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

La Fontana Sorellena

4.53/5
324 reviews from 3 sources
885 Annadale Road, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Max's es-CA

4.50/5
3062 reviews from 4 sources
1559 Richmond Rd, Staten Island
Details Write a review

Panini Grill

4.50/5
1717 reviews from 3 sources
538 Forest Ave, Staten Island
Details Write a review
MAP LIST