Show filters
Sort by
  1. Find companies
  2. Italian Restaurants
  3. Key West
Hold On!

Don’t leave so soon. You can test our service for

30 days for free!
Start now

The best Italian Restaurants in Key West

14 results with 32634 reviews from multiple sources

Big John's Pizzeria

4.72/5
6057 reviews from 4 sources
1103 Key Plz, Key West
Details Write a review

Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria

4.70/5
4030 reviews from 3 sources
516 Fleming St., Key West
Details Write a review

Mr Z's

4.58/5
3685 reviews from 4 sources
501 Southard St, Key West
Details Write a review

Antonias Restaurant

4.54/5
2987 reviews from 4 sources
615 Duval Street, Key West
Details Write a review

Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

4.52/5
2137 reviews from 4 sources
613-1/2 Duval St, Key West
Details Write a review

Mangia Mangia

4.46/5
1806 reviews from 3 sources
900 Southard Street, Key West
Details Write a review

New York Pasta Garden

4.44/5
1902 reviews from 4 sources
1075 Duval St, Key West
Details Write a review

Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria

4.43/5
1907 reviews from 4 sources
5620 Macdonald Ave, Key West
Details Write a review

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

4.42/5
1266 reviews from 4 sources
1208 Simonton St, Key West
Details Write a review

Onlywood Grill

4.38/5
1905 reviews from 4 sources
725 Caroline Street, Key West
Details Write a review

Bistro 245

4.32/5
3615 reviews from 4 sources
245 Front St, Key West
Details Write a review

Terrace Roma

4.29/5
560 reviews from 4 sources
300 Front Street, Key West
Details Write a review

Angelina's Pizzeria

4.09/5
709 reviews from 4 sources
208 Duval Street, Key West
Details Write a review

Paradise Pizza

3.55/5
68 reviews from 3 sources
503 Greene St, Key West
Details Write a review
MAP LIST