Show filters
Sort by
  1. Find companies
  2. Italian Restaurants
  3. Columbus
Hold On!

Don’t leave so soon. You can test our service for

30 days for free!
Start now

The best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

56 results with 94090 reviews from multiple sources

Basi Italia

4.81/5
5645 reviews from 4 sources
811 Highland Avenue, Columbus
Details Write a review

Gallo's Kitchen & Bar

4.80/5
2521 reviews from 4 sources
2820 Nottingham Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Pasqualone's

4.76/5
572 reviews from 4 sources
5766 Emporium Square, Columbus
Details Write a review

Papa Giorgios

4.74/5
486 reviews from 4 sources
5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus
Details Write a review

Pizza House

4.71/5
2015 reviews from 4 sources
747 E Lincoln Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Martini Modern Italian

4.69/5
7176 reviews from 4 sources
445 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Emelio's Restaurant

4.69/5
1205 reviews from 4 sources
574 Georgesville Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Smith's Deli & Restaurant

4.66/5
781 reviews from 4 sources
3737 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Adriaticos New York Style Pizza

4.60/5
4118 reviews from 3 sources
1618 Neil Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Rubino's Pizza

4.59/5
1466 reviews from 4 sources
2643 E MAIN ST, Columbus
Details Write a review

Z Cucina

4.59/5
3025 reviews from 4 sources
1368 GRANDVIEW AVE, Columbus
Details Write a review

Trattoria Roma

4.57/5
2522 reviews from 4 sources
1447 Grandview Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Bistrolino Old World Kitchen & Bar

4.57/5
759 reviews from 4 sources
495 S 4th St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Mama Mimi's Take N Bake Pizza

4.58/5
178 reviews from 4 sources
2923 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Villa Nova Ristorante

4.54/5
4568 reviews from 4 sources
5545 N HIGH ST, Columbus
Details Write a review

Rotolo's Pizza

4.55/5
547 reviews from 3 sources
1749 W 5TH Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Marcella's

4.54/5
5059 reviews from 2 sources
1319 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus
Details Write a review

Borgata Pizza Cafe

4.52/5
1723 reviews from 4 sources
5701 Parkville St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Giuseppe's Ritrovo

4.49/5
852 reviews from 4 sources
2268 E Main St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Minnelli's Pizza

4.48/5
1053 reviews from 4 sources
1189 N Wilson Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Tarantos Pizzeria

4.48/5
630 reviews from 4 sources
1282 EAST POWELL ROAD, Columbus
Details Write a review

Dante's Pizza

4.47/5
364 reviews from 4 sources
3586 Indianola Ave., Columbus
Details Write a review

Claudiana Italian Restaurant

4.44/5
1620 reviews from 4 sources
8475 Sancus Blvd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Pasta Villa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.42/5
1291 reviews from 4 sources
2475 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Big Tony's Pizza and Pasta

4.38/5
521 reviews from 4 sources
1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Cafe Napolitana Pizzeria

4.36/5
391 reviews from 4 sources
40 NORTH HIGH STREET, Columbus
Details Write a review

TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia

4.35/5
1150 reviews from 3 sources
1210 S James Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Carsonie’s Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen

4.34/5
656 reviews from 4 sources
1725 W Lane Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Due Amici

4.31/5
4206 reviews from 4 sources
67 E Gay St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Tommy's Pizza

4.31/5
1614 reviews from 4 sources
1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Gatto's Pizza

4.31/5
441 reviews from 4 sources
2928 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Piada Italian Street Food

4.29/5
3552 reviews from 4 sources
2585 East Main Street, Columbus
Details Write a review

Don Gino's Pizza

4.27/5
626 reviews from 4 sources
5283 W Broad St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Paul's Fifth Avenue

4.27/5
1018 reviews from 4 sources
1565 W 5th Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Angelinas Villa

4.27/5
704 reviews from 4 sources
5450 E Livingston Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Carrabba's Italian Grill

4.26/5
2581 reviews from 3 sources
8460 Lyra Drive, Columbus
Details Write a review

CATFISH BIFFS PIZZA & SUBS

4.29/5
165 reviews from 3 sources
75 W 11Th Ave, Columbus
Details Write a review

Brunos Pizza & Restaurant

4.24/5
343 reviews from 4 sources
1774 EAST DUBLIN GRANVILLE ROAD, Columbus
Details Write a review

Iacono's Pizza & Restaurant

4.16/5
505 reviews from 4 sources
4452 Kenny Road, Columbus
Details Write a review

Massey's Pizza

4.16/5
714 reviews from 4 sources
261 Lincoln Cir, Columbus
Details Write a review

Anges Pizza

4.14/5
832 reviews from 3 sources
139 SOUTH YEARLING ROAD, Columbus
Details Write a review

W.G. Grinders Catering

4.14/5
603 reviews from 4 sources
2820 Fishinger Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Spaghetti Warehouse

4.12/5
10505 reviews from 4 sources
397 WEST BROAD STREET, Columbus
Details Write a review

Pochi Cafe

4.14/5
353 reviews from 4 sources
921 E Johnstown Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

DeARINI'S TAVERN & GRILL

4.12/5
195 reviews from 4 sources
1942 Henderson Rd, Columbus
Details Write a review

Portofino's Pizza

4.10/5
294 reviews from 3 sources
1497 N High St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Vino Vino

4.07/5
146 reviews from 4 sources
1371 GRANDVIEW AVE, Columbus
Details Write a review

Pastaria At North Market

4.04/5
95 reviews from 3 sources
59 Spruce St, Columbus
Details Write a review

Luigi's City Pizza

4.00/5
81 reviews from 2 sources
1069 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus
Details Write a review

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

3.92/5
5777 reviews from 4 sources
343 N Front St, Columbus
Details Write a review
MAP LIST